Super Losses Exceed 500 Million
The First Guardian Collapse
If you’ve been following financial news lately, you might have seen alarming headlines about the collapse of the First Guardian Master Fund. This financial disaster has left thousands of Australians worried about the security of their hard-earned superannuation savings. With over $500 million reportedly lost, it raises serious questions about how these funds operate and the risks associated with moving your retirement nest egg.
In a recent segment on ABC Radio Melbourne, share market specialist Remo Greco joined Lisa Leon to unpack what went wrong, what investors need to know about platforms and wraps, and how to protect your super from similar risks.

What Happened With First Guardian?
According to Greco, the First Guardian Master Fund and its related product, the Shield Master Fund, were marketed aggressively to Australians as promising alternatives for their superannuation. There was reportedly an unrelenting sales campaign, using persistent phone calls and possibly social media, that pressured people to transfer their existing super into these new funds.
The hook? The funds claimed to deliver superior performance and better returns an enticing prospect for anyone planning for retirement.
But behind the sales pitch was a system that eventually crumbled. When First Guardian collapsed, it left thousands of investors with their super accounts drained, sparking outrage and fear.
The Backbone of Modern Investing
Part of the story involves investment platforms, which played a key role in how these funds were accessed. But what exactly is a platform?
Greco explained it using a simple analogy. Think of a platform like your online banking app. When you log in, you can see all your accounts savings, credit cards, term deposits and move money between them easily.
In the world of investing, platforms work similarly. They are large technology systems that allow advisors and investors to view and manage multiple investments shares, managed funds, bonds all in one place. This convenience eliminates the cumbersome paperwork traditionally required for each individual transaction.
These platforms aren’t obscure tech either; they’re run by well-known institutions like Macquarie, AMP, and other big names in the financial industry.

Who Actually Holds Your Money?
A common question for investors is: “Who’s actually holding my super? Is it the platform or my advisor?”
Greco clarified that platforms themselves don’t hold your money. Instead, they act as a record-keeping and transaction system, keeping track of your investments and allowing your advisor to move funds between products seamlessly. The actual investments whether cash accounts, managed funds, or shares remain with the respective financial institutions managing them.
This setup is designed for efficiency and flexibility, but as the First Guardian case shows, it also requires trustworthy advisors and regulated products to ensure your money is safe.
Lessons Learned: Protecting Your Superannuation
The collapse of First Guardian serves as a sobering reminder that “better returns” often come with higher risks. For Australians, it underscores the importance of vigilance when it comes to their super.
Here are some key takeaways:
- Do your homework. Before switching super funds, research the product thoroughly and check its regulatory approval.
- Be wary of high-pressure tactics. If you’re being pushed to make a decision quickly, that’s a red flag.
- Understand where your money goes. Know the difference between platforms, advisors, and fund managers.
- Seek professional advice. Only work with licensed financial advisors who are bound by fiduciary duty to act in your best interest.
As Greco noted, while technology has made investing easier than ever, it’s also created opportunities for unscrupulous operators to take advantage of unsuspecting savers.